Jill Buckshot, a former Miss Algonquin Nation, stole steaks from an Ottawa grocery store and sold them to support her addiction. (via Unequal Justice: Aboriginals caught in the justice system trap | Toronto Star)
- Buckshot, who became addicted at 25 after having surgery and taking a prescribed narcotic for the pain, would steal steaks from an Ottawa grocery store by hiding them under large packages of toilet paper. Then she’d sell them for half-price.
- “I got caught up in the system,” says Buckshot, 30. The former Miss Algonquin Nation, who came ninth out of 32 contestants in the 2002 Miss Indian World competition, was last released from an Ottawa jail in September.
- Her story is common among aboriginal women and men. While admissions of white adults to Ontario jails fell 20 per cent between 1992 and 2009, the number of aboriginal inmates continued to go up, even as crime rates went down.
- Aboriginal people accounted for less than 2 per cent of Ontario’s adult population in 2009, but more than 10 per cent of adults admitted to provincial jails. In federal penitentiaries, they are nearly 20 per cent of inmates.
- Proportions are even more skewed when it comes to young offenders. Aboriginal girls account for one of every three jail admissions to a provincial facility for female youth, according to data obtained by University of Toronto doctoral candidate Akwasi Owusu-Bempah through a freedom-of-information request. That is 10 times higher than their proportion of the province’s youth population.
- Among male youth in jail, aboriginal boys make up 15 per cent. In the general Ontario population, they account for only 3 per cent of boys, which means they are overrepresented in jail by a factor of five.
- In a report released Tuesday , former Supreme Court justice Frank Iacobucci harshly criticized the judicial system for “systemic racism” and labeled the marginalization and jailing of aboriginals a “serious crisis.”
- In 2009-10, of young offenders convicted for assault, about 25 per cent of aboriginal youth were sent to jail, compared with less than 15 per cent of non-aboriginal youth. Similar discrepancies exist for theft and possession, and break-and-enter crimes.
- Manitoba, where upwards of 50 per cent of inmates are aboriginal, is one of the provinces building new jails. In 2012, MP Carolyn Bennett toured the Women’s Correctional Centre in Headingley, Man., which has an exercise room, elders’ room and “beautiful chalets” where women in custody can keep their children until they’re of school age. “Everything seemed like progress, until I asked the superintendent what they’re all here for,” says Bennett, the Liberal critic for Aboriginal Affairs. “And what she said was, practically none of them were initially sentenced to jail … Almost all of them had some sort of community sentence with conditions. And with one slip — say they go home for a funeral and associate with someone they’re not supposed to — they end up incarcerated.”
- Is it racism? Not always, at least not overtly, he says. Judges may assume that the arrest of a middle-class kid is embarrassing enough in and of itself, and that belief may play a part in sentencing. Judges may hand out stricter punishments to kids from rougher parts of town because they think those kids won’t experience equivalent shame. Judges in remote areas of the province may assume there’s no good diversion program available.
- Although Ontario’s last residential school closed more than 30 years ago, the impact of abuse and separation continues into the next generations. Students sent away to school as young as 6 were taught discipline instead of loving parenting. “Residential school parents talk about the fact that they were never able to hug their children. They were never able to tell their children they loved them,” says Rudin. “And that has an impact.” The legacy of physical and sexual abuse is passed down to third and even fourth generations, who turn to alcohol and drugs to cope, he says. The effects snowball, and they go on to lose their children.
- Ontario has never tracked the relationship between foster care and jail. But a 1995 study of a Saskatchewan penitentiary, part of the Royal Commission Report on Aboriginal Peoples co-written by Rudin, found that 95 per cent of the aboriginal inmates had at some point been adopted or in foster care. Advocates say there is a correlation between the underfunding and hardship endured by aboriginal families and the fact so many kids are in foster care.
